It has been an interesting day to say the least. This afternoon I installed the rating system (commonly referred to on SoberCircle as the Thumbs). Feedback was mixed. Several people liked the idea. Others were really upset. As you can read from my previous post Regulating open blogs in a social networking community, the intentions are good and pure. So many people see this type of system as a popularity contest, when in truth the Post Read total we post next to the blogs in the list post a much greater representation to popularity than this “thumbs” system ever would. We aren’t even displaying the number of positive responses for a blog to prevent this beauty pageant. Most members felt that there was a high probability they would be excluded from the public eye because of this and they immediately felt threatened. The truth is, it will take a lot of negative opinions to get bumped from the public eye.
Inevitably, someone will have a post get bumped off the list. This is the equivalent of forcing a person to sit down and pass the mic after going off on a rant about something that to the group is irrelevant. Its the harsh truth about public exchange of communication, every once and again you have to put someone in check for their carelessness or indiscretions. My responsibility as a community leader is to facilitate free communication and empower the user base while insuring the vast majority of members and visitors get the most out of the website. I take this responsibility seriously. So, I had to go back after the system was launched and add a page back that shows all the blogs regardless of whether they get bumped off the main list or not. What this does is allows the members to have it their way, just like Burger King.
Ah, the life of a social network developer, always listening to your membership, making changes and assessing the effect – both positive and negative. It’s not a lot of fun to have to answer questions from your members in an open chat after you make a dramatic change to such an important section of the website, but you have to step up and be accountable. Otherwise, you lose the faith of the people….